Skip to main content
Sports

Garcia vs Haney 2: Why We Can’t Pretend It Never Happened

8 min read
9 views
FN

Frank Nyambe

Nov 12, 2026

Garcia vs Haney 2: Why We Can’t Pretend It Never Happened
ShareFacebookLinkedInXWhatsApp

Imagine the biggest fight of the year takes place. Three knockdowns. A roaring arena. Arguments in every barbershop, group chat and comment section on the planet. Then the result gets changed to a no contest, and the sport shuffles forward like someone just misplaced a receipt.

That, in a nutshell, is the story of the Ryan Garcia vs Devin Haney rematch that never came. And I’m sorry, but I refuse to nod along. We cannot just pretend a fight that big never happened.

In this post, I’ll walk through what went down, why Garcia vs Haney 2 still makes perfect sense today, and why a welterweight unification between the WBC and WBO champions is exactly the kind of fight boxing should be begging for.

What Actually Happened in Garcia vs Haney 1

Let’s rewind to April 2024. Ryan Garcia floored Devin Haney three times and walked away with a majority decision on the scorecards. Garcia also missed weight, which meant Haney’s title was never going to change hands that night. Then came the plot twist nobody ordered: Garcia tested positive for the banned substance ostarine.

The New York State Athletic Commission suspended him for one year, fined him, and changed the result to a no contest. Garcia has always maintained that he never knowingly took anything, and that is his side of the story. Whatever you believe about how it got into his system, the punishment was handed down, and Garcia served it.

Here’s what I respect: he faced it like a man and came back. He returned to the ring, won the WBC welterweight title, and defended it this September by stopping Conor Benn in two rounds. That’s a full comeback arc, and any storyteller would be proud of it.

Here’s what bugs me, though. As far as I can tell, the fight itself just got filed under “moving on.” No dramatic announcement. No “we’ll run it back, properly.” It felt like a studio releasing a blockbuster, spotting a continuity error in the final scene, and deciding the sequel was optional.

A simple horizontal timeline graphic in a dark navy and gold boxing-poster style with four milestones: “April 2024: Three knockdowns, majority decision”, “Positive ostarine test”, “Result changed to no contest, one-year suspension”, “2026: Garcia returns and becomes WBC welterweight champion”.

Why a Mandatory Rematch Made Sense

I’ll be honest, I don’t know how they do things in boxing. Maybe there’s a rulebook thicker than a phone book and a contract clause hiding in every corner. But Garcia faced his punishment, so why not order a rematch? And I don’t mean a polite suggestion. I mean a mandatory rematch.

Sanctioning bodies exist to keep the sport credible and the big fights happening. This was one of the biggest fights in boxing, and nobody stepped up to say, “Gentlemen, let’s do this again.”

A mandatory rematch could have come with stricter terms: tougher drug testing, firm weight rules, consequences written clearly in ink. Let me be very clear, I’m not suggesting Garcia is likely to use performance enhancing drugs again. Stricter terms would simply protect the fighters, the fans, and the fight itself. No surprises, no drama, no asterisks.

Because right now, that is what the first fight carries: one giant asterisk. Asterisks belong in footnotes, not on the biggest fight of the year. And the only way to scrub that one off is to settle it in the ring.

And timing matters. Big fights are like fresh bread; they taste best while they’re warm. Every month that passes, the public’s memory shifts from “when is the rematch?” to “whatever happened to that fight?” Garcia is 28, Haney is 27, both are champions, both are in their prime, and both have momentum. Waiting for a better moment only risks missing the moment entirely.

Styles Make Fights, and These Two Are Pure Chemistry

Beyond the politics, the matchup itself is irresistible. Garcia has a left hook that has ended nights early and a right hand that floored Conor Benn just before the finish. Haney is a technician, unbeaten as a pro, who captured a world title with pure skill and discipline.

Haney has even admitted he underestimated Garcia the first time. That tells me he’d walk into a rematch as a different man. Power versus polish. Speed versus sharpness. A second fight wouldn’t be a repeat; it would be a different movie entirely.

And sequels only work when the second chapter changes something. Here, everything changes: the weight class, the belts, the stakes, and a fighter with something to prove. Garcia would carry a hard-earned belt and a rebuilt reputation; Haney would carry a belt of his own and a point to prove.

Where Garcia vs Haney 2 Stands Right Now

Here’s where it gets spicy. Devin Haney has called a Ryan Garcia rematch the biggest fight in boxing, and he wants it. Garcia, meanwhile, told Ring Magazine in August that he would never fight Haney again unless Haney admits something shady went on around his positive test. That claim is Garcia’s, it hasn’t been proven, and the anti-doping expert he pointed to dismissed it as a conspiracy theory.

Then, in early October, the two reportedly traded Instagram messages. Garcia asked whether he had to remind Haney again, and Haney replied, “Let’s make the fight.” Oscar De La Hoya has also said a Haney or Teofimo Lopez fight should be next for Garcia, with May 2027 floated. Both men sound willing to talk, which, in boxing, counts as a romantic gesture.

On October 21, Garcia announced that he and Floyd Mayweather had agreed to fight at 147 pounds for the WBC title. Mayweather has since said he’ll tune up in December before facing Garcia in February. Nothing is signed that I know of, so I’d file all of it under “rumour until the ink dries.”

Now, I respect Floyd. He’s one of my top two favourite fighters, and no, don’t ask me to name the other, or their order. 😄 But Garcia vs Mayweather? Eh. I’d rather see the fight that answers the questions people have been asking since April 2024. Garcia vs Haney 2 settles a real score. A Mayweather bout settles a headline.

Unify the Belts, Guys

Even if nobody in boxing cares about the word “mandatory,” the fight still makes sense for both men. Garcia holds the WBC welterweight title. Haney holds the WBO version. Put them in a ring at 147 pounds, or whichever weight they agree on, and let the belts do what belts are supposed to do: get unified.

Haney is already set to face IBF champion Liam Paro on December 19 in San Francisco in a unification bout of his own. If he wins, he’ll hold two belts to Garcia’s one, and the stakes of a rematch climb even higher. Business-wise, it’s hard to design a cleaner setup.

So what’s stopping you, guys? Contracts, promoters, streaming platforms and pride are all fair answers, and I know there’s more going on behind the scenes than fans like me will ever see. But the fight is there. The demand is there. The story is practically writing itself.

Let me say it plainly: I’d love to see a unification of the belts, and I’d love to see the rematch. Doing both in one night is the kind of efficiency even your accountant would applaud.

A clean photo of the WBC and WBO welterweight belts side by side on a dark wooden table under a single spotlight, with a pair of boxing gloves resting beside them and a handwritten sticky note that reads “Please unify. Thanks.”

The Shakur Stevenson Factor

Then there’s Shakur Stevenson, and man, a unification showdown with Devin Haney would be a great fight. The two came close, with Stevenson accepting a 145-pound catchweight in October. Then talks collapsed over weight and negotiation details, and both camps blamed each other publicly. Right now, the fight is off.

I recognise there’s more to a fight than what the rest of us know: deals, contracts and whatnot. Maybe Stevenson has his reasons. Here’s what I do know. His mentor, Terence Crawford, would have gone for that fight in a heartbeat. Those are the kinds of fights Crawford took, marking his territory and leaving no questions asked.

In my opinion, a unification showdown with Haney weighs even more than the Gervonta “Tank” Davis fight that came up at some point. It’s the bigger fight, and a cleaner test of who’s really at the top. Fights like this are how legacies get built.

Haney Earned His Flowers Against Norman Jr.

I have to give credit where it’s due. I didn’t think Devin Haney would beat Brian Norman Jr. the way he did. I wasn’t even picking a side; I thought it could go either way. Then Haney went out in November 2025 and put on a brilliant performance, winning a unanimous decision and the WBO welterweight title.

Maybe that’s why some of the other guys are hesitant to face him. (I’m joking. 😃) But seriously, great performance. Haney isn’t a name from the past begging for a rematch; he’s a current champion who earned his seat at the table, and that makes the case for Garcia vs Haney 2 even stronger.

Final Thoughts: Make the Rematch Happen

Boxing thrives on unfinished business, and Ryan Garcia vs Devin Haney is as unfinished as it gets. Three knockdowns, a positive test, a changed result, a year-long suspension, a comeback, and two champions holding welterweight belts. And honestly, if boxing had a plot twist budget, this feud spent it all by 2024. Pitch that as a script and someone would say it’s too much.

The first fight can’t be erased. It can only be answered. Whether it’s a mandatory rematch, a voluntary one, or a full unification of the WBC and WBO welterweight titles, Garcia and Haney owe the fans a second chapter.

So, gentlemen, make it happen.

Tags
Ryan Garcia vs Devin Haney rematchGarcia vs Haney 2Devin HaneyRyan Garciawelterweight unification